Emotional vs. Physical Hunger: How to Tell the Difference (and What to Do About It)
Let’s be real — not every snack attack is about hunger.
If you’ve ever found yourself standing in front of the pantry after a long day, looking for something (but you’re not quite sure what), you’re not alone. Emotional eating is a normal, common experience — but when it becomes your default, it can stall your progress toward fat loss, energy balance, and overall health.
In a recent coaching call with our 12-Week Nutrition Challenge group, Jennie Carolan, MS, our lead nutritionist at APEX PWR, broke it down in the way only she can.
“So many of our food choices happen for reasons beyond physical hunger — and that’s normal,” Jennie shared. “But when emotional eating becomes our default, it can stall progress and leave us feeling stuck.”
Whether you live near our gym in Tigard, Oregon, in Beaverton, or across the country, this guidance can change your relationship with food.
Emotional Hunger vs. Physical Hunger
Jennie outlines the key differences:
- Physical hunger builds gradually, any food sounds appealing, and it goes away once you’ve eaten enough.
- Emotional hunger feels urgent, is usually tied to a specific craving (like chips, cookies, or ice cream), and may linger even after eating.
This difference matters — because when you treat emotional hunger like physical hunger, it can lead to frustration, guilt, and a cycle that’s hard to break.
What to Do Instead: Simple Tools That Work
Here are a few simple, but powerful tools Jennie uses with our clients in the 12-Week Nutrition Challenge and 1-on-1 coaching:
🛑 Try the HALT Check-In
Ask yourself:
- Hungry?
- Angry?
- Lonely?
- Tired?
“The HALT tool is simple but powerful,” Jennie says. “It helps you pause and figure out what’s really going on before you turn to food automatically.”
⏱ Take the 10-Minute Pause
Give yourself a short break when a craving hits. Step outside. Walk around. Breathe. Then check back in.
“It helps shift from reaction to intention,” Jennie explains. “Even just 10 minutes can change everything.”
📓 Journal Before and After Eating
Note what triggered your eating — a feeling, an event, a habit. This builds awareness over time.
“Awareness always comes before change,” Jennie reminds her clients. “The more we can recognize the patterns, the easier it becomes to change them.”
☕ Find Other Soothing Habits
Instead of automatically reaching for food, consider:
- A warm drink
- Calling a friend
- Stepping outside for 5 minutes
“Food can be comforting — and that’s okay,” says Jennie. “But it doesn’t have to be the only comfort tool.”
The Bottom Line: Food Is Emotional — and That’s Okay
This isn’t about removing all emotion from food. Food is a celebration. Culture. Connection. Comfort.
But when food becomes the only way we manage stress, fatigue, or frustration, it creates a loop that’s tough to escape.
“This is about building awareness,” Jennie says. “So that food becomes one of your tools — not the only one.”
Nutrition Help for Portland, Beaverton — and Beyond
Even though APEX PWR is located in Tigard, Oregon, Jennie works with nutrition clients across the country through our virtual coaching programs.
Whether you’re local to the Portland Metro area or located in another state, you can receive expert guidance from a licensed nutritionist to help you build habits that last — no crash diets, no guilt, no shame.
And as a bonus, if you’re in our area, we provide the gold standard in body composition analysis, the DEXA Scan. This is a great way to gather objective data to see more than just one number on the scale in the bathroom.
We focus on education, empowerment, and support that works in real life.
Ready to Take the Next Step?
If emotional eating has been holding you back, we’re here to help. Whether through our 12-Week Nutrition Challenge or customized coaching, Jennie can help you build a plan that fits your lifestyle and goals.
Previous Blogs
Corporate Wellness in Portland, OR: How to Help Your Organization Elevate Health, Fitness, and Performance
Corporate Wellness in Portland, OR: How to Help Your Organization Elevate Health, Fitness, and Performance At APEX PWR in Portland, OR, we believe the success of any organization is directly tied to the health, wellness, and performance of its people. That is why we provide corporate wellness solutions designed to meet the needs of companies
Choosing the Right Diet: Insights from Peter Attia and APEX PWR
Choosing the Right Diet: Insights from Peter Attia and APEX PWR Nutrition is one of the most misunderstood and debated areas of health and wellness. Everyone has heard arguments about keto, carnivore, vegan, or Mediterranean diets. Each has its champions and each has critics, but for most people the endless back-and-forth only leads to more
Creatine is on the Rise! Thorne’s New Creatine Flavors + Travel-Friendly Packs at 25% discount!
Creatine is on the Rise! Thorne’s New Creatine Flavors + Travel-Friendly Packs at 25% discount! At APEX Performance Wellness & Rehab (APEX PWR), we’re always looking for ways to make high-quality supplements more accessible and enjoyable for our community. Creatine has long been one of the most researched and trusted supplements for strength, energy, and