APEX PWR  |  Athlete Angle

Malik Nabers Had to Get Hit Before He Trusted His Knee

I want to talk about something that happened in a football game last Sunday, because it said more about injury recovery than most things I have read on the subject.

Malik Nabers, the Giants receiver, played his first game since tearing his ACL and meniscus last October. 350 days. He was not a lock to play. The reporting going in was that the knee was medically fine and that he was not sure he could be himself on it, which is a different problem entirely and a much harder one to fix.

So before the game, in warmups, his head coach John Harbaugh tackled him. Actually tackled him. Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart described the thinking: once Nabers got hit for the first time and realized he was okay, he would feel confident. Harbaugh put him on the ground, then told him, "See, you're all good."

Nabers played. Six catches on nine targets for 69 yards, second on the team, in a 28-20 divisional win over Dallas. And when he took his first real hit in live action, Harbaugh was right there on the sideline to meet him, because that moment mattered more than the yardage did.

Here is the line from Nabers that I keep coming back to. He said it was "a one-on-one battle that you gotta go through," and that he had to do it for himself first. He did not even invite his family to the game, because he did not want to feel like he had let them down if he could not go.

Read that again if you are the parent of an injured athlete. A professional receiver, with a full-time medical staff, a strength staff, and every resource in the sport, was privately carrying that.

Why Confidence Is a Rehab Problem, Not a Personality Problem

When an athlete says "it just doesn't feel right," the instinct is to reassure them. Your scans are clean. Your therapist cleared you. You are fine.

That rarely works, because they are not asking for information. They are asking for evidence, and reassurance is not evidence. What Harbaugh gave Nabers was not a pep talk. It was a controlled rep of the exact thing he was afraid of, in a setting where the cost of it going badly was low.

That is a rehab principle, and it is one we use deliberately at APEX. You expose the athlete to the thing they are avoiding, in graded doses, under supervision, with a coach or a therapist watching, until the fear runs out of evidence.

What Our Physical Therapy Team Actually Does

Most people's picture of physical therapy stops at pain and range of motion. Get the swelling down, get the knee bending, get the limp out of the walk. That work matters, and it is the first thing our team does, but if that is where it ends, the athlete gets discharged into a gap.

Our physical therapy team in Tigard is built around four jobs, in order.

The testing piece is the one I would underline for parents. A calendar does not know anything about your kid's knee. Numbers do. When our staff decides an athlete is ready for the next progression, that decision is anchored to measured capacity and to current evidence on return to sport, not to a date on a wall or a general sense that enough time has passed.

Our staff includes Dr. Jon van den Boogaard, PT, DPT, OCS, who directs our testing protocols, and Dr. Jordan Prunty, PT, DPT, who works extensively with ACL reconstructions, alongside Dr. Dustin Zink and Dr. Kevin Le. If you want the longer version of how we run an ACL specifically, we have written about it here: physical therapy for ACL rehab and from the first steps to full return.

The Handoff Is Where Most People Lose It

Here is the failure I see most often, and it has nothing to do with the quality of anyone's rehab.

An athlete finishes physical therapy somewhere, gets a discharge sheet, and is sent back into the world with a few exercises and no plan. Six weeks later the strength they rebuilt is leaking away, because nothing is loading it anymore. Then they get hurt again and everyone calls it bad luck.

The discharge is not the finish line. It is a handoff, and handoffs get dropped when the two people involved have never met.

At APEX, they work in the same building. Young athletes coming out of physical therapy move into our semi-private sports performance training, where the coaches already have their testing numbers and know which side was the surgical side. Adults move into one-on-one personal training with a coach who can see the rehab notes. Either way, the progression keeps going instead of stopping and restarting.

What I Would Tell a Parent Watching Their Kid Go Through This

• The fear is normal and it is not weakness. A pro receiver needed his head coach to tackle him. Your 15-year-old is allowed to be unsure.
• Do not make readiness a conversation about toughness. Nabers kept his family away so he would not feel like he was letting them down. Kids do a version of that too, and it usually looks like saying they feel fine when they do not.
• Ask for numbers. Whoever is treating your athlete, ask what they are measuring and what the target is before the next progression. If the answer is only about weeks since surgery, ask more questions.
• Make sure somebody is looking above and below the injury. I rehabbed a knee and ignored the hip and the ankle attached to it, and I paid for that for a year. If the plan only ever touches the surgical site, it is not a plan.
• Plan for what happens after discharge on day one. Not after the last visit. The strength they rebuild has to have somewhere to go.
• Let them get hit in a controlled setting before it counts. Whatever that means for their sport. The first live exposure should not be the first game.

We Will Be Watching This One

Nabers is 350 days out and one good game in. Coming back is not a single Sunday, it is a season of Sundays, and there will be a week where the knee is sore and the doubt comes back. That happens to everyone, at every level.

What he has going for him is a coach who understood that the mental hurdle was the real one and did something concrete about it instead of telling him to be tough. That is coaching. It is also, if you strip out the tackling, exactly what good rehab looks like.

Patrick Mahomes came back from an ACL and LCL tear the same weekend and had a completely different obstacle in front of him. I wrote about that one too, and it is the one where my own story gets uglier: Mahomes came back from an ACL tear and started slow, and that is the normal part.

Frequently Asked Questions