APEX PWR  |  Physical Therapy Feature

Mahomes Came Back From an ACL Tear and Started Slow. That Is the Normal Part.

Two athletes came back from ACL surgery on the same weekend, and between them they tell the whole story of what a comeback actually is.

I wrote about Malik Nabers separately, because his hurdle was confidence and his coach solved it by tackling him in warmups. Patrick Mahomes had a different problem, and I think it is the one more of you will recognize.

What Actually Happened

Mahomes tore his ACL and his LCL in December against the Chargers and had surgery the following day. He came back 274 days later to open the season against Denver.

The first stretch of that game was rough. He completed 2 of his first 12 passes. If you were watching and looking for evidence that the knee had taken something from him, you had it.

Then on an early drive, a play broke down, he climbed up through the rush, planted on the surgically repaired leg, and ran it in from 15 yards out, diving past two defenders closing on him. That is the single most informative rep of the whole afternoon. Not because of the touchdown. Because of the plant.

He finished five straight completions before the half. In the second half he went 7 of 9 for 122 yards. Final line: 15 of 27 for 184 yards, two touchdowns, one interception, and a 31-10 win in a division game.

Why the Quarterback Comparison Is Useful for Regular People

Quarterback is a strange job, and it makes a good teaching example.

Your eyes have to be downfield. You are reading a defense, tracking a safety, waiting an extra half second for a receiver to come open. Which means the thing that is about to hit you is almost always something you cannot see and cannot brace for. You have to give up self-protection to do the job well.

Most people returning from surgery are doing a smaller version of that every day. You are carrying a kid down the stairs. You are stepping off a curb in the rain in Beaverton. You are reaching for something on a high shelf and your foot slips a little. The demand is not the max effort rep. The demand is the unplanned one.

That is why we do not consider someone finished when they can do a controlled exercise in a controlled room. Real life is not controlled. The end of rehab has to include chaos on purpose, in graded doses.

What Our Physical Therapy Team Does Differently

Three things, and none of them are complicated. They are just uncommon in the same building.

1. We measure instead of guessing

Our therapists use VALD force plates, dynamometry and speed gates to put numbers on limb symmetry, how much force you produce, how fast you produce it, and how you absorb a landing. Those get retested through the process, so every progression is based on measured capacity and on current return-to-sport evidence rather than on how many weeks have passed. A calendar knows nothing about your knee.

2. We treat the return as a separate phase, not an afterthought

Pain-free and range-of-motion normal is the beginning of the back half, not the end of the work. The physical therapy we run carries through to actual demands: cutting, landing, decelerating, reacting to something you did not plan for. For an active adult that might mean loaded carries and uneven ground rather than agility drills, but the principle is the same.

3. We do not discharge you into nothing

This is the part I care most about. Strength you stop loading is strength you start losing. The traditional model ends with a printed sheet and a handshake, and six weeks later most people have quietly given a chunk of it back.

At APEX, rehab and training share a roof. Adults move from physical therapy into one-on-one personal training or small group adult strength training with a coach who can see the rehab notes. Young athletes move into semi-private sports performance training with their testing numbers already in hand. You should not have to re-explain your surgery to a stranger at a commercial gym in order to keep making progress.

If You Are in the Middle of This Right Now

• Expect an ugly first outing. Mahomes went 2 for 12 to start and finished with a blowout win. Judge the return over weeks, not over one afternoon.
• Watch the mechanics, not the outcome. The 15-yard scramble told us more than the completion percentage did, because it showed the knee doing something violent and unplanned. Ask your therapist what the equivalent moment is for you.
• Do not use somebody else's timeline. Mahomes was back at 274 days and Nabers at 350, both professionals with full-time staffs. Your number is your number.
• Urgency is the enemy, and it is very persuasive. I had a legitimate reason to rush back in college and it still cost me more than waiting would have. Whatever your deadline is, senior season, a race, a trip, it is not worth a second surgery.
• Have a plan for after discharge before you get there. Decide who is keeping you strong in month six, month nine, month twelve.
• Tell someone the truth about how it feels. The private math is where people talk themselves out of sports, and out of activity in general.

We Will Keep Watching Both of Them

Nabers and Mahomes are one week into long seasons. There will be a game where a knee is sore, or a throw comes out wrong, or somebody in the stands decides out loud that the player is not what he was. That happens at every level of sport and it happens in ordinary life too, six months after a surgery, when you tweak something and immediately assume the worst.

It is worth watching how they handle it, because comebacks are not one good Sunday. They are a long series of days where you keep showing up and let the evidence accumulate.

More comeback pieces we have written: Cameron Brink and the power of patience, lessons from Paige Bueckers for JuJu Watkins, and Joel Embiid and meniscus rehab, which is the one closest to my own history.

Frequently Asked Questions